Johnny Muir (6/17/2008 8:12:00 AM)
Hi, I work for the BBC in Belfast and am working on a documentary to mark Seamus Heaney's 70th birthday. His work is studied (and written about in exams) by people all over the world and I am trying to find out what impact it has them. In this poem he writes about events in pre-historic Ireland - yet it clearly has a resonance om our time. I would love to hear anyone's comments on what Heaney's poetry means to them. Tell me about individual poems that have made an impact on you and why!
Cheers,
johnny.muir@bbc.co.uk |
Laura Brooks (5/13/2008 6:43:00 AM)
We studied this poem in great length, and I am in fact just about to do an exam involving it. The poem possesses great depth, Heaney sympathizing with the woman. She was an adulteress and, though her lover went unpunished, she was killed in such a brutal manner. She was a 'scapegoat' for the crimes committed by both of them, not just one. Very well written. |
Laura Brooks (5/13/2008 6:43:00 AM)
We studied this poem in great length, and I am in fact just about to do an exam involving it. The poem possesses great depth, Heaney sympathizing with the woman. She was an adulteress and, though her lover went unpunished, she was killed in such a brutal manner. She was a 'scapegoat' for the crimes committed by both of them, not just one. Very well written. |
Celeste Butler Mendez (11/28/2006 1:18:00 PM)
This reminds me of events that could have happened to any black woman during slavery times. Arthur is extremely talented poet. |
Akella S.ratnam (11/3/2006 12:04:00 AM)
The poem is a sad reminder of the brutal ways of punishment.More than the punishment inflicted onthe woman it is the cllous attitude of the perpetrators who stand as mute spectators to the inhuman and unethical ways of mankind. |
Kennan Crane (3/17/2006 2:02:00 PM)
I think Heaney connects the punishment of this woman with the 'punishment' of the women who associated with British soldiers in 1960's Ireland. These women were tarred and chained railings in public places by the IRA. Heaney sympathizes both with the women being punished and with their persecutors, noting that he understands the 'the exact / and tribal, intimate revenge.' I think this is one of Heaney's best. |
Steve Risinger (1/10/2006 12:09:00 PM)
is this refering to past traditions as he Heaney feels he has a connection with old Galic ways? |
