Thursday, January 1, 2004

Robinson Crusoe's Story Comments

Rating: 3.2

THE night was thick and hazy
When the 'Piccadilly Daisy'
Carried down the crew and captain in the sea;
And I think the water drowned 'em;


Charles Edward Carryl
Sandy Rollins 18 November 2021

I learned this poem in a little country school in the 1950's. I thought of it on the way to visit my sisters a couple days ago. I started reciting it in the car and my husband joined me. We went to different schools. We had to laugh. I am 76 and he is 80. Memories

0 0 Reply
Jess McVey jr. 11 April 2021

My father, a career navy man, on occasion having returned from the tavern, would recite this one and a few more exceptionally well.

0 0 Reply
Bette Hewlett 04 November 2020

I have always loved this poem! When I was in grade five in Enderby, B C, we learned it & I'm happy to say I still remember it except the verse about the garden. Of course, maybe that verse wasn't included in our poetry book! (Right!)

1 0 Reply
Barbara 09 April 2020

We had to learn this poem in Grade 8. I am now 89 years old and I still can repeat it without an error.

5 0 Reply
Tadrisi Mazumder 06 April 2020

Summary of the poems are very much required for proper understanding of the poems.

2 0 Reply
Barbara Bewley 11 December 2019

Had to memorize this poem in Grade 8. I am now 88 and still can recite it

2 0 Reply
Warisha Ahmed 21 January 2019

I my school it was my poem of class 6

3 1 Reply
Vanessa Wells 06 December 2018

When my Dad was at Middlebury College (Vermont) , he came upon this poem and set it to music. I memorized it, verses and melody. Now my sisters and children know it too. Delightful!

3 1 Reply
Susan Van Meter 28 June 2018

I learned this poem when I was about 8 years old and I thought of it recently (at age 84) and remembered parts of it. So glad to find it on the internet. I hope today's children are still learning poetry. It was more fun than anything else in school.

9 3 Reply
Dfyfgftcycycycycyc 19 February 2018


3 2 Reply
Marilyn from Indiana 13 February 2018

I learned it also at an early age and I can still repeat a lot of it

5 1 Reply
Barbara 06 February 2018

I had to memorize this poem in Grade 8 and I am now 87 and can still repeat it.

7 1 Reply
* Sunprincess * 14 January 2017

......a fantastic poem, I love the rhyming ?

5 1 Reply
Wes Vogler 28 August 2016

This is my all time favourite poem bar none. We have quoted him for many years and still delight in the whimsy. I am now using his narrative style when not doing limericks (Louise part 24)

6 5 Reply
Kelly Kurt 28 August 2016

He certainly has perfected this form

0 0 Reply
Susan Williams 24 January 2016

Robinson Crusoe through the eyes of a happy soul!

18 6 Reply
Susan Williams 24 January 2016

Robinson Crusoe through the eyes of a happy soul! If this poet was in reality shipwrecked, I suspect that this would be the kind of life he would live. Amusing and delightful write for children of all ages!

26 4 Reply
Ratnakar Mandlik 24 January 2016

Amazing write. Amusing and entertaining too. Thanks for sharing.

5 3 Reply
Wes Vogler 07 November 2015

What a crock is this Suparna Koley. Carryl was bright and whimsical, something for which Koley does not allow. He had a good time writing a funny poem with nothing in it concerning hidden meanings. He was amusing his audience and did just exactly that. Koley, hush up. You are making a fool of yourself. Perhaps if you had said I think what he meant was... then that is your opinion and might be acceptable. But do not deign to state facts of which you cannot be sure.

5 8 Reply
Suparna Koley 01 August 2013

To the fact...scholars-he meant the development he had was progressing his knowledge gradually through the hardships and innovative way to overcome it.He has become one of the most important scholars in the island where he was exiled and found out the ways to protect him. I t was his wisdom, the knowledge and the urge to explore more for the crisis moments. But he mentioned all the scholars, that means he wanted to mean those ACCOMPANY proved their intellegence and its practise instead of their blunt animality. They became expert of self development with different skill and activities. are correct about their collars-here he wanted to mean the behavior and intelligence are gradually rectified by themselves with a method of try and error.As Crusoe was very close to the animals accompanied him in the island, the collars being the behaviours and module of works were being changed by the situation and conditioned thrusted upon them.Their collars meant the behaviours of animals mentioned in the previous stanza were being unveiled to him. and particular turning out their toes- meant The way they wanted to prove his work . He pointed out the activities of scholars and their tool to share time and experience a midst the strong tide of lonely island where each and every corner was unknown to them.. Robinson Crusoe tried to know particular their worthiness of knowledge. suparna koley

10 14 Reply