Poetics and Poetry Discussion
(9/8/2005 10:00:00 AM)
One of the definitions for Critical (and its various and sundry derivations) in MW is: 'exercising or involving careful judgment or judicious evaluation.' The popular usage of the term has given it, in my opinion, an unjust qualification. When we critique someone's work, our aim should not be destruction, but rather the author's good, the improvement of his/her work or technique. If we aim only to harm or destroy, then we are, as you say, arrogant and mean. Perhaps some do this due to frustration with thier own lack of talent? I don't know, I can only fall back on the tried and true, mean people suck.
Poetry is about beauty and/or truth (some truths being ugly, these may be mutually exclusive terms in some cases) Critiqueing it should be only about truth, as gently told as possible. Jealosy and mean-spiritedness (is this a real word?) should have no place, though, since we are human they will find thier way in.