Great Poetry? Poem by Smoky Hoss

Great Poetry?

Rating: 5.0


How could anyone ever truly
Define great poetry?
Factors are so many that contribute
To the way each person does hear-feel-and see.
The season, the day, the very time,
Along with each readers wisdom-knowledge-and mind.
A line read one day
May deeply stir the spirit
While the very next time read
The reader simply just can't 'get-it'.

Besides, who is to judge,
And who is to decide?
Who always speaks truth,
And who pray tell has never lied?
Let the one who has never struggled with emotion and word
Cast the first critical stone,
Let the pure, perfect poet
Read and write completely all alone;
Enshrined by himself
Upon his own empty throne.

After all, it is supposed to be
A bit (or more) of myth and mystery,
A little difficult to decipher, somewhat vague,
Meant to speak, but not brag.
For Goodness sake, it's poetry.
Not prose, not essay, and certainly not the news.
It's forms are many and free,
It's thoughts different and deep,
It's direction everywhere the heart can see,
It's origin, and destination, ineffable...

But to write, one must try, or die... such is the poems strength.
So, let the creator of words create.
With wild and wonderful words to decipher and debate;
And never let the beauty of it all
In trivial criticism suffocate.

What is great poetry though you still inquire?
I should have told you from the start;
(But, then you would not have listened)
Great poetry is always, and only,
Beautiful words written truly
From, and for, the heart.

COMMENTS OF THE POEM
Biff Mcguire 23 June 2011

Hey Smoky, This one gives hope to all of us lest we drown in 'trivial critisim' Big ten! Biff

2 0 Reply
Juan Olivarez 24 January 2011

Reading your poem Smoky I came to realize that I have been guilty of a lot of the things you describe. So it did not make me laugh Like Jenny, and I guess that proves your point. Who is to judge, very wise words I gave you a ten.

0 0 Reply
Jenny Gordon 15 January 2011

Fascinating. I loved this! Made me laugh. I only take exception at the 'for...sake', made me wince and wish there was another way to make your point than that. 'Twas quite the enjoyable discussion/consideration.....I suppose all of us who set down our darling cogitations aspire however half-heartedly at writing 'great poetry' and you generously leave room for all of us if we are sincere. I cannot successfully disagree, but to meet Shakespeare's mark would be something of an achievement, in my estimation.

1 0 Reply
READ THIS POEM IN OTHER LANGUAGES
Close
Error Success