What Cannot Be Said Poem by Mirza Ghalib

What Cannot Be Said

Rating: 3.2


There's one who took my heart away.
But does she own it? I can't say.

See her as unjust though I may,
Is she a tyrant? I can't say.

She strides a bloodless battlefield
Where there's no battle-axe to wield.

She keeps a wineless banquet-hall
Where there's no bowl to raise at all.

Although she serves wine ceaselessly,
Her fingers bring no cup to me.

Her idol-carving hand is sure,
But you cannot call her Azer

When riots quiet down, why must
You brag of ousting the unjust?

There will be nothing you can say
Of the unjust on Judgment Day.

Within the breast the secret lies
Which none can ever sermonize.

How strange a thing it is that throws
The mind askew till no one knows

How I Ghalib am no believer
But can't be called unfaithful either.

<b>Note: </b>
Azer: in the Islamic tradition, Abraham's father who manufactured and served Nimrod's idols. Known as Terah in the Judeo-Christian tradition.

[Trasnlated from Persian ]

COMMENTS OF THE POEM
M Asim Nehal 19 March 2016

Superb poem, The depth in this poem is amazing. Thanks for sharing.

10 0 Reply
Subhas Chandra Chakra 21 November 2017

An amazing poem shared. Thanks Mirza Saab.

4 0 Reply
Rajnish Manga 17 February 2020

Each couplet is perfectly translated with sweet rhyme and poetic beauty. Thanks.

1 0 Reply
Edward Kofi Louis 17 February 2020

She took my heart away! ! ! But, she doesn't own it. Beautiful! Thanks for sharing this poem with us.

1 0 Reply
Mahtab Bangalee 17 February 2020

truth ultimate truth lives in known and unknown seen and unseen in intuition and realistic life for the untouched truth none can name me I'm defamer of God or I'm loyal to God Yes I'm on this earth pieces into truth! ! ! ! !

1 0 Reply
Dr Antony Theodore 30 July 2020

She strides a bloodless battlefield Where there's no battle-axe to wield. She keeps a wineless banquet-hall Where there's no bowl to raise at all.. very good poem. Tony

0 0 Reply
Sarah Persson 17 February 2020

This is a beautiful poem, congratulations on Poem of the Day :)

0 0 Reply

I must say, " it is simply beautiful"

0 0 Reply
Sally P. P. 17 February 2020

Food for thought. Enjoyed the flow of words.

1 0 Reply
Ramesh T A 17 February 2020

Wonderful verse with amazing ideas to muse over!

1 0 Reply
READ THIS POEM IN OTHER LANGUAGES
Mirza Ghalib

Mirza Ghalib

Agra / British India
Close
Error Success